RFE
12 Sep 2019, 11:45 GMT+10
A one-day public hearing was held on September 11 in Ukraine's case against Russia for its alleged human rights abuses in Crimea.
The European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) in Strasbourg is being asked to rule, among other issues, whether Russia effectively controlled the Ukrainian territory before the State Duma on March 20, 2014 ratified a treaty that Russian President Vladimir Putin signed as part of the annexation process.
Kyiv insists Moscow controlled the peninsula since February 27, 2014 and that Russian forces tortured and killed police as well as civilians, allegations that Moscow denies.
Other atrocities of which Kyiv accuses Russia include harassment and intimidation of priests and journalists, which the Kremlin also denies.
Speaking first at the hearing, Russian Deputy Justice Minister Mikhail Galperin said at the time of Crimea's takeover, Ukraine lacked a constitutionally legitimate government and the country was run by "fascists" who don't tolerate "minority languages," he said referring to Russian.
Galperin acknowledged there were Russian soldiers in Ukraine's Crimean Peninsula at the time Moscow took it over, but in numbers that were prescribed by the 1997 Black Sea fleet agreement.
Any evidence Kyiv presented on human rights abuses is unreliable and taken from "third-party sources" and not from on-the-ground monitoring, he said.
Galperin warned the court of opening a Pandora's box of politically motivated cases, which could lead to the ECHR being flooded with many more in the future.
"Ukraine's written submissions are defective in many ways because they're political" and are based "more on propaganda than direct evidence," Galperin said.
Ukraine dismissed Galperin's arguments that it didn't commit atrocities in Crimea by pointing to independent findings from the United Nations that corroborate Kyiv's allegations.
Ben Emmerson, a British lawyer on Ukraine's legal team, said Russia didn't allow investigators into Crimea, which is why more witness testimony wasn't available. He cited a report by the UN Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights regarding human rights violations, including the torture of Ukrainian officers using electric shocks and knives.
"There is serious and credible evidence that requires serious investigation and [it] more than meets the admissibility threshold," Emmerson said.
Ukraine has filed four more cases with the ECHR against Russia. For simplification, the court has separated cases relating to Crimea and Donbas in eastern Ukraine where a Russian-backed separatist conflict is being waged.
An ECHR ruling wasn't expected on September 11 and won't be delivered until the court finishes deliberating.
With reporting by The Babel, Ukrainska Pravda, and Bloomberg
Copyright (c) 2018. RFE/RL, Inc. Republished with the permission of Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty, 1201 Connecticut Ave NW, Ste 400, Washington DC 20036
Get a daily dose of Massachusetts Sun news through our daily email, its complimentary and keeps you fully up to date with world and business news as well.
Publish news of your business, community or sports group, personnel appointments, major event and more by submitting a news release to Massachusetts Sun.
More InformationMADRID, Spain: Liverpool footballer Diogo Jota and his younger brother, André Silva, have died in a car accident in Spain. Spanish...
LONDON, U.K.: An unrelenting heatwave sweeping across Europe has pushed early summer temperatures to historic highs, triggering deadly...
President Donald Trump's plans to build a space-based Golden Dome missile defense shield have drawn immediate criticism from China,...
NEW YORK CITY, New York: Paramount has agreed to pay US$16 million to settle a lawsuit brought by U.S. President Donald Trump over...
LONDON, U.K.: British Prime Minister Keir Starmer won a vote in Parliament this week to move ahead with changes to the country's welfare...
WASHINGTON, D.C.: President Donald Trump will meet Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu at the White House on Monday. President...
FRANKLIN, Tennessee: Hundreds of thousands of Nissan and Infiniti vehicles are being recalled across the United States due to a potential...
REDMOND, Washington: Microsoft is the latest tech giant to announce significant job cuts, as the financial strain of building next-generation...
LONDON UK - U.S. stock markets were closed on Friday for Independence Day. Global Forex Markets Wrap Up Friday with Greeback Comeback...
SANTA CLARA, California: Nvidia came within a whisker of making financial history on July 3, briefly surpassing Apple's all-time market...
SACRAMENTO, California: California's multibillion-dollar farms are facing a growing crisis—not from drought or pests, but from a sudden...
WASHINGTON, D.C.: President Donald Trump says the United States could soon reach a trade deal with India. He believes this deal would...